Bo Bichette Next Team Odds – Will Toronto Hold or Deal Its Star Shortstop?

Overview of the Event

The future of Bo Bichette has quickly become one of baseball’s most-watched offseason storylines.
As the Toronto Blue Jays navigate roster decisions and long-term payroll balance, oddsmakers have opened markets on where their star shortstop could play next.

The Next Team odds reflect growing speculation that Toronto could explore a retool or soft reset before 2026, especially if extension talks stall. Bettors are paying close attention to how front-office language and trade rumors align through the Winter Meetings and spring training window.

Recent Context

A proven contact hitter and two-time All-Star, Bichette has been a mainstay of Toronto’s offense since debuting in 2019.
Injuries and lineup inconsistencies limited his 2024 production, but his .290+ career average and approach at the plate keep him among the league’s most reliable infielders.
MLB.com +1

Contending clubs with middle-infield needs — including the Los Angeles Dodgers, St. Louis Cardinals, Chicago Cubs, and New York Yankees — have all been linked as potential trade destinations. Toronto, meanwhile, faces the challenge of deciding whether to rebuild or recommit to its current core.

Contenders to Watch

🔵 Toronto Blue Jays

Still the favorite to retain him. Management could push for a multi-year extension rather than trigger a mid-cycle rebuild.

⚾ Los Angeles Dodgers

A consistent factor in major player markets. If they miss on other marquee names, Bichette’s bat fits perfectly into their lineup.

🔴 St. Louis Cardinals

One of the league’s most trade-active teams. Bichette would immediately upgrade their infield production and lineup consistency.

⚪ New York Yankees

Always in play for elite position talent. Bichette’s contact profile and right-handed power align perfectly with Yankee Stadium.

🔵 Chicago Cubs

A forward-thinking roster with payroll space and a need for veteran leadership. A legitimate dark-horse option.

Key Factors to Consider

• Contract & Arbitration Window: Bichette’s remaining club control gives Toronto leverage — but complicates extension negotiations.

• Team Direction: If the Blue Jays pivot toward a younger core, Bichette could headline trade packages.

• Market Timing: Winter Meetings, injury updates, and front-office statements heavily influence market odds.

• Infield Demand: Several playoff-caliber teams lack offensive depth at shortstop.

• Player Fit: Bichette’s balanced skillset translates across both leagues, widening the range of realistic suitors.

Quick Summary

Current Team: Toronto Blue Jays
Position: Shortstop
Status: Under team control through 2026
Betting Focus: Trade potential, contract talks, and team strategy
Best Sources: MLB.com, The Athletic, Sportsnet, Fangraphs, Bleacher Report